Tool Alpha
The Contradiction Desk
Claimed Bible contradictions, stated the way they circulate, each with one diagnosis and the evidence for it: the Hebrew, the Greek, the manuscripts.
Forty thousand stalls, or four thousand?
1 Kings 4:26 gives Solomon forty thousand stalls for his chariot horses. 2 Chronicles 9:25 gives him four thousand. One Hebrew manuscript of Kings reads four thousand too.
1 Kings 4:26, in every translation this tool compares.
The real question: how many stalls did Solomon have, and is one of the books wrong? The listing says the barn holds 40,000 bales, and the owner says 4,000. Is one of them exaggerating, or is there a stray zero?
1 Kings 4:26 says Solomon had forty thousand stalls of horses for his chariots. 2 Chronicles 9:25 says four thousand stalls for horses and chariots. Both give twelve thousand horsemen.
The ESV prints 40,000 at 1 Kings 4:26 and footnotes: Hebrew; one Hebrew manuscript reads 4,000, pointing to 2 Chronicles 9:25 and to the Septuagint of 1 Kings 10:26. The CSB's textual note at 1 Kings 4:26 says 2 Chronicles 9:25 reads 4,000 stalls. The NIV prints four thousand in Kings, as the NIV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible's note shows. MacArthur calls 4,000 the preferable reading.
And Solomon had forty thousand stalls of horses for his chariots, and twelve thousand horsemen.
The Skeptic's Annotated Bible asks "How many stalls did Solomon have?" and sets 40,000 against 4,000. At full strength: forty thousand is the figure in the Hebrew text of Kings, and the correction comes from one manuscript and a parallel book.
The NIV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible grants that some read the large numbers as literary hyperbole, as in other kings' annals, but says the excavated chariot cities such as Megiddo and the large chariot forces recorded in ancient battles support the possibility that they are accurate. The CSB Study Bible notes that ancient literature often used numbers symbolically and asks readers to weigh that before taking them literally.
The copying diagnosis brings Kings down to 4,000. It does not settle whether 4,000 is itself a literal count. The IVP Bible Background Commentary on 2 Chronicles 1:14 says the Megiddo stables could have held up to 480 horses and that nearly 800 stalls can be identified across the excavated stable sites, which is far below either figure. That bears on the size of Solomon's force, not on which text is original.
Not a claim that archaeology refutes the verse. Excavated stalls are a minimum, not a full count.
- ESV Study Bible, footnote on 1 Kings 4:26
- CSB Study Bible, textual note and note on 1 Kings 4:26
- NIV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible, note on 1 Kings 4:26
- The MacArthur Study Bible (ESV), note on 2 Chronicles 9:25
- John H. Walton, Victor H. Matthews and Mark W. Chavalas, The IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament (InterVarsity Press), comment on 2 Chronicles 1:14
- The Skeptic's Annotated Bible, How many stalls did Solomon have?, https://skepticsannotatedbible.com/contra/stalls.html
- King James Version, 1 Kings 4:26 and 2 Chronicles 9:25
