Brass armillary sphere and a dark globe on a wooden desk beside a worn leather book and blank cards, faint fire-rings over a quiet planet in a stone window

Tool Alpha

C. S. Lewis’s Cosmology

Where Lewis’s heavens follow Scripture, where they come from the medieval picture of the cosmos, and where he made them up.

The Deep Magic

The White Witch claims Edmund by the law built into Narnia. Aslan dies in his place, and a deeper magic undoes death. Lewis drew the shape from the popular atonement drama of the Middle Ages.

From the medieval modelThe Bent One and the fallNarnia
Colossians 2:13-15

Colossians 2:13-15, in every translation this tool compares.

First, in plain English

The real question: what is the Deep Magic, and why does Aslan have to die? The contract says the house goes to the bank. Everyone agrees on the contract. The surprise is a clause older than the bank. Lewis builds Aslan's death on that kind of turn, and where he got it is what the boxes below sort out.

What Lewis wrote

The Witch reminds Aslan of the Deep Magic the Emperor put into Narnia at the beginning: "every traitor belongs to me as my lawful prey." Aslan dies in Edmund's place on the Stone Table. After he rises he explains that there is "a magic deeper still," from before time, by which the death of a willing victim who has committed no treachery in a traitor's place makes the Table crack and death itself start working backward.

The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, chs. 13 and 15
The biblical picture

Colossians 2 says God cancelled the record of debt against us, nailing it to the cross, and disarmed the rulers and authorities. Hebrews 2 says Christ through death destroyed the one who has the power of death. Mark 10:45 calls his life a ransom for many. Scripture does not say to whom a ransom is paid, and it never says God outwitted the devil.

Where he got it

McGrath traces the shape to the popular religious literature of the Middle Ages, especially the mystery plays: Satan has a right over sinful humanity, God outwits him because Christ is sinless, and the risen Christ breaks down the gates of hell and frees its prisoners, the Harrowing of Hell. McGrath notes Lewis knew theology mostly through literature, and that Lewis said theories of the atonement were secondary to the fact of it.

Where he departs

The Witch's legal right over traitors, and the trick by which she loses it, come from medieval drama, not from the New Testament. McGrath records that most theologians find Lewis's depiction muddled, and argues they misread his sources and his aim.

What this is not

Not a worked-out theory of the atonement. Lewis said he would not invent one, and McGrath reads the Stone Table as a story in the tradition of the mystery plays, not a doctrine.

Read with the Divine Council Index
  • {"u":"https:\/\/jayms.com\/bible-study-tools-2\/divine-council-index\/1-peter-3-18-22\/","n":"1 Peter 3:18-22","s":"Christ proclaims to the spirits in prison, the ones disobedient in the days of Noah.","r":"1 Peter 3:18-22"}
Sources
  1. Lewis, The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (1950), chs. 13 and 15
  2. McGrath, C. S. Lewis, A Life (2013), The Deeper Magic: Atonement in Narnia

All entries

Favorites
Timelines
Words and Translation
People, Places and Powers
The World Behind the Text
Claims and Questions
One Book at a Time
Printables
Facebook X Substack