Tool Alpha
Genesis, the Beginning
What the first eleven chapters say, what they do not say, and where the real arguments are.
The tree of the knowledge of good and evil
One tree, one command, no reason given. What the tree was, and why it was off limits, is read three ways.
Genesis 2:9, in every translation this tool compares.
The real question: what was the tree, and why was it forbidden? The car keys are on the counter. Don't touch them. A sixteen-year-old can hear that as a test of whether he listens, or as a line about who decides when he is ready to drive. Same rule, two readings, and readers of Genesis 2 split much the same way.
Genesis names two trees in the middle of the garden, gives one prohibition, and attaches no reason to it. After they eat, God says the man has become like one of us, knowing good and evil. What did the tree stand for?
The phrase is the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. In 3:5 the serpent says that eating will make them like God, knowing good and evil, and in 3:22 God says the man has become like one of us in that knowledge. The NIV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible notes that nothing is known of this tree from any ancient Near Eastern tradition.
For God doth know that in the day ye eat thereof, then your eyes shall be opened, and ye shall be as gods, knowing good and evil.
Lennox says we need not discuss the nature of the fruit or what quality it had. Reading it that way misses the point. The first humans had the capacity to eat from every tree but not the permission to eat from one, and that is what made them moral beings. To do anything contrary to the will and word of the Creator is itself lawlessness. He quotes Theophilus of Antioch: "It was not the tree, as some think, but the disobedience which had the death in it."
Walton reads the tree of the knowledge of good and evil as a tree of wisdom. Adam and Eve had access to immortality through the tree of life but lacked wisdom, the reverse of the sage Adapa in Mesopotamian tradition, who had wisdom but not immortality. Their sin was choosing to make themselves the centre of order and the source of wisdom, instead of receiving wisdom in relationship with God. The garden and trees are symbols in his reading, which he says does not mean they were not real.
The MacArthur Study Bible reads the tree as a test of obedience, with nothing magical about it. Eating it after it was forbidden would give the knowledge of evil, since evil can be defined as disobeying God, and man already had the knowledge of good.
Lennox's reading explains the prohibition but not why the tree carries this name. Walton's has to explain why wisdom, which Proverbs urges everyone to get, is forbidden here; his answer is that the problem is the source, wisdom seized apart from God. The test reading has to explain why a test of obedience is named for knowledge at all.
Not a story about a fruit with powers. Lennox and the MacArthur Study Bible both put the death in the disobedience, not the fruit. Walton reads the tree as standing for something beyond itself.
- {"u":"https:\/\/jayms.com\/bible-study-tools-2\/divine-council-index\/genesis-3-1-15\/","n":"Genesis 3:1-15","s":"The nachash in the garden, and the sentence passed on it.","r":"Genesis 3:1-15"}
- Lennox, Seven Days that Divide the World (2021), ch. 4, quoting Theophilus of Antioch
- Walton, The Lost World of Adam and Eve (2015), propositions 13 and 15
- NIV Cultural Backgrounds Study Bible, ed. John H. Walton and Craig S. Keener, note on Genesis 2:9
- The MacArthur Study Bible (ESV), notes on Genesis 2:9 and 2:17
