A linen cloth abandoned on a thorn bush beside a dropped travelling pack where a track forks above the coast — who was Mark in the New Testament
,

Who Was Mark in the New Testament? (2 of 4)

·

Series: Who Wrote the New Testament · Part 2 of 4

Mark is the man who walked out.

He left a mission partway through, and the argument about whether to take him again was sharp enough to break up the most effective missionary partnership in the early church. Paul refused. Barnabas insisted. They separated over it.

Years later Paul asks for him by name and says he is useful.

Who Was John Mark?

A Jerusalem man from a household the church used.

Acts 12:12 puts Peter, newly walked out of prison, going to the house of Mary the mother of John called Mark, where a group had gathered to pray. That is a specific and revealing detail. Mark’s mother owned a house in Jerusalem large enough for the church to meet in, with a servant at the door, which suggests means.

He is a cousin of Barnabas, which explains a good deal of what follows.

The double name is ordinary. John is the Hebrew name and Mark is the Roman one, and a Jerusalem family with Roman connections would use both.

Why Did Mark Leave Paul and Barnabas?

Scripture does not say, which has not stopped anyone guessing.

He set out with Barnabas and Saul as their helper, and at Perga in Pamphylia he left them and returned to Jerusalem. That is the whole account in Acts 13:13. No reason is offered.

The proposals over the centuries include homesickness, fear of the difficult country ahead, discomfort as Paul displaced Barnabas as leader of the party, and unease about the direction the Gentile mission was taking. Each is plausible and none is stated.

What the text does record is how seriously Paul took it. When Barnabas wanted to bring Mark on the next journey, Paul judged it unwise to take someone who had deserted them. The word Acts uses for the resulting disagreement is strong. They parted company, Barnabas took Mark to Cyprus, and Paul took Silas.

Did Paul and Mark Ever Reconcile?

“Get Mark and bring him with you”: The quarrel is in Acts, the reconciliation is in the letters, and readers rarely see them together
The quarrel is in Acts, the reconciliation is in the letters, and readers rarely see them together

Yes, and the evidence is scattered across three letters.

Col 4:10 sends greetings from Mark, names him as Barnabas’s cousin, and tells the church to welcome him if he comes. Phlm 24 lists him among Paul’s fellow workers.

The strongest is 2 Tim 4:11. Paul, near the end, alone except for Luke, tells Timothy to get Mark and bring him, because he is useful to him for ministry.

That sentence is worth sitting with. The man Paul refused to travel with is the man Paul sends for at the end. The New Testament records the rupture without flattening it and then records the repair without announcing it.

Was Mark Peter’s Interpreter?

That is the earliest tradition about how the Gospel came to be written, and it is a strong one.

Papias, writing in the first half of the second century and preserved by Eusebius, says Mark became Peter’s interpreter and wrote down accurately what he remembered of Peter’s preaching, though not in order.

The tradition is early, it was repeated widely, and no ancient writer disputes it.

It also fits something outside itself. 1 Pet 5:13 sends greetings from the church in Babylon, widely read as code for Rome, and from Mark, whom Peter calls his son. Independently of Papias, that puts the two men in the same city late in Peter’s life.

Tradition and text arriving at the same arrangement from different directions is the kind of convergence that gives a claim weight.

Is Mark the Young Man Who Ran Away Naked?

A very old guess with nothing behind it.

Mark 14:51-52 reports that as Jesus was arrested, a young man following him, wearing only a linen cloth, was seized, and he left the cloth and fled naked. The detail appears in no other Gospel and serves no obvious purpose.

The traditional suggestion is that this is the author signing his own work, the way a painter puts himself at the edge of a crowd scene. It is a satisfying idea.

It is also entirely speculative. The text does not name him, no early writer identifies him, and the whole case rests on the oddity of the detail plus the assumption that an odd detail must be personal.

Hold it as an attractive possibility and nothing more.

Did Mark Found the Church in Alexandria?

Tradition says so, and the tradition is later than the ones about Rome.

Eusebius reports that Mark was the first to be sent to Egypt and preached the gospel there and established churches in Alexandria. The Coptic Orthodox Church traces its founding to him and has done so for a very long time.

The claim comes centuries after the events and appears in a historian assembling succession lines for major sees, which is exactly the context where such a claim is most useful and least checkable.

Held as a living tradition of an ancient church, it deserves respect. Held as history it sits considerably below the Rome material, which has both an early witness and a corroborating text.

Part of a series on the New Testament writers who were not among the Twelve.

Continues from Part 1: Who Was Luke and Did He Write Acts?  ·  Continues in Part 3: Who Wrote the Book of Jude?

All 4 parts in this series
  1. Part 1Who Was Luke and Did He Write Acts?
  2. Part 2Who Was Mark in the New Testament?You are here
  3. Part 3Who Wrote the Book of Jude?
  4. Part 4Who Was James the Brother of Jesus?

New field notes when they are ready, along with the research underneath them. No drip sequence, no course, nothing to buy.

Subscribe to the newsletter →

Footnotes2
  1. The Paul and Barnabas split is one of the few places where the New Testament records a serious personal conflict between leaders without resolving it in the moment. Acts reports the disagreement, reports the separation, and moves on. That the repair shows up years later in a different letter, unannounced, is a striking way for a document collection to handle a quarrel.
  2. Papias's qualification that Mark did not write in order has driven discussion of the Gospel's structure ever since. It is worth noticing that the qualification is part of the original claim rather than a defensive addition by later writers, which suggests Papias was reporting something he had received rather than constructing a defence.
Sources

Papias, preserved in Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History 3.39. Supports the Mark-as-Peter's-interpreter tradition and the qualification about order. Free in full at the Christian Classics Ethereal Library.

Eusebius of Caesarea, Ecclesiastical History 2.16. Supports the Alexandrian foundation claim. Same access.

Where the sourcing stops: the survey of proposed reasons for Mark's departure at Perga is a summary of common suggestions, none of which the text supports. The weighing of the Alexandrian tradition against the Roman one is my own judgment about the relative strength of the evidence.


Favorites
Timelines
Words and Translation
People, Places and Powers
The World Behind the Text
Claims and Questions
One Book at a Time
Printables
Facebook X Substack